How to Remove the Xfinity Modem Rental and WiFi Fees

Comcast Xfinity charges a standard $14 per month for your Wifi modem and router, or $25 if you opt for their premium in-home mesh xFi Pods. It appears on page 3 of your monthly bill under 'regular monthly charges' as a 'modem rental.' You can remove the fee by using your own modem and router, instead of leasing the equipment from Xfinity.

Plan Tier Plan cost WiFi Router Fee Annual WiFi Lease Cost WiFi Equipment Policy
Performance Starter+ (25 Mbps) $29.99 $14 per month $168 Own equipment permitted
Performance Select (100 Mbps) $34.99 $14 per month $168 Own equipment permitted
Performance Pro+ (200 Mbps) $49.99 $14 per month $168 Own equipment permitted
Blast! Pro+ (300 Mbps) $64.99 $14 per month $168 Own equipment permitted
Extreme Pro+ (600 Mbps) $74.99 $14 per month $168 Own equipment permitted
Gigabit (1000 Mbps) $84.99 $14 per month $168 Own equipment permitted
Xfinity Internet Essentials (25 Mbps) $9.95 Included Free $0 WiFi Equipment included

WiFi fee removal Compatable modems/routers Included WiFi models Why charge?

Xfinity has been pushing their in-home mesh networking equipment, called “xFi Pods,” since 2018. While the pods cost an extra $25 per month ($300 annualized), they include unlimited data, which otherwise costs $30 per month as a standlone add-on with Xfinity.

This can be frustrating when comparing Xfinity to other cable providers like Spectrum who offer unlimited data for free — but until the FCC does something about it, which they probably won’t, that’s the policy.

A quick note for non-techies:

  • Modem: the device that hooks into your cable jack and connects you to the internet.
  • Router: the device that plugs into your modem and broadcasts WiFi for your home.

With Xfinity, the modem and router are usually combined into one device. They call it a "wireless gateway" when you sign up. However, you'll likely be buying them separately if you opt to use your own.

Enter an address to view alternative internet companies in your area. AT&T and Earthlink are the most common alternatives to Xfinity.

How to remove the Spectrum in-home Wi-Fi fee

The easiest way to get rid of the modem rental or “WiFi equipment fee” with Xfinity is to simply use your own equipment.

Purchasing your own modem and router will run you around $120, or less if you get used or refurbished models.

The cost can go up to $200 if you want to get a higher-end mesh network setup like the Eero or Google Nest; but even then, you’ll be getting your money back in less than a year compared to the $300 annualized cost of leasing a mesh networking setup from Xfinity directly.

Even the basic modem rental provided by Xfinity costs $14 per month, or 168 per year. As you can see in this table, that’s high for the industry, especially for a basic piece of equipment with no bells and whistles:

Internet ProviderMonthly Base WiFi FeeAnnual cost of WiFi equipment leaseService type
Xfinity$14$168Cable, Fiber
AT&T$10$120DSL, Fiber
Spectrum$5$60Cable
Cox$10.99$131.88Cable
Frontier$10$120DSL, Fiber

If you’re an existing Xfinity customer, you can find your plan in this table to see how your annual cost will compare if you drop the WiFi fee:

Plan NamePrice with WiFi feePrice with WiFi fee removedWifi FeeWiFi fee annualized
Performance Starter+ (25 Mbps)$64 ($43.99 first 12 months)$50 ($29.99 first 12 months)$14/mo.$168/yr.
Performance Select (100 Mbps)$69 ($48.99 first 12 months)$55 ($34.99 first 12 months)$14/mo.$168/yr.
Performance Pro+ (200 Mbps)$84 ($63.99 first 12 months)$70 ($49.99 first 12 months)$14/mo.$168/yr.
Blast! Pro+ (300 Mbps)$94 ($78.99 first 12 months)$80 ($64.99 first 12 months)$14/mo.$168/yr.
Extreme Pro+ (600 Mbps)$104 ($88.99 first 12 months)$90 ($74.99 first 12 months)$14/mo.$168/yr.
Gigabit (1000 Mbps)$114 ($98.99 first 12 months)$100 ($84.99 first 12 months)$14/mo.$168/yr.

As you can see, it adds up quickly.

My advice with Xfinity is to either use your own equipment to drop the fee, or opt for the xFi Pods. The middle ground of leasing an expensive low-grade modem/router for $14 per month is simply a bad value.

The pricing on the pods is high, but at least you get all the extra features like network monitoring, unlimited data, parental controls, free service visits, etc.

Note that when you purchase your own equipment, Xfinity will often try to blame issues on your modem when you have technical problems. So, only use your own equipment if you’re comfortable doing basic troubleshooting, and can speak about it confidently enough to convince their tech support the issue is on their end.

I’ve written up a full guide to every trick for lowering your Xfinity bill as an existing customer here.

Swapping out the Xfinity modem for your own

The process for switching to your own modem and router with Xfinity is pretty easy:

  1. Purchase the modem and router(s) of your choice. (Recommendations below.)
  2. Call Xfinity technical support and provide the MAC address on your new modem so they can turn on your service.
  3. Plug in your new equipment and confirm it’s working.
  4. Return the Xfinity equipment at an Xfinity store location. (This is important, otherwise they can’t credit you for the equipment fee.)
  5. Confirm the fee is removed from you bill next month, and call to dispute if it’s still there (this is common).

Modems and routers compatible with Xfinity

Xfinity maintains a full list of compatible modems at their website. Here are the two I recommend for most people:

Ease of install: Surfboard modem + router combo unit

The Arris Surfboard is the best pick for any Xfinity plan below 500 Mbps download. It's extremely easy to install, and should last for years.

The surfboard has gigabit ethernet ports, dual-band 2.4 and 5 Ghz WiFi network options, and everything else your average user needs to run a basic smarthome and home office.

View on Amazon

Ease of use: Eero mesh

There are several mesh networking systems on the market, including offerings from Google and Plume. However, Eero was the first, and their hardware is the most reliable for the price.

Mesh networking kits are pricey — the Eero can cost $200 or more. However, the features justify it, particularly if you are in a large home that tends to get WiFi dead spots.

Eero works by placing several access points around the home, which work in tandem to concentrate coverage where your devices are and make sure there are no dead spots. They also have easy-to-use apps for setup and maintenance, giving you much more data about your network without having to be a techie to figure it out.

View Eero

What modem and router does Xfinity internet come with

Something that makes Xfinity unique among cable providers is that they maintain a comprehensive line of Xfinity-branded modem and WiFi router devices, which they call “gateways.”

The full specs for each generation of the Gateway are maintained on their site, but to summarize:

  1. Xfinity gateways are manufactured by Comcast for their exclusive use.
  2. The mesh network option, xFi Pods, includes hardware designed in partnership with Plume.

Why does Xfinity charge for WiFi?

Xfinity charges for WiFi service because they have their own line of home networking equipment that is designed to plug into their other offerings, which include home security, smart home and locks, media systems, and more.

While the cost is high relative to other cable providers, it does provide a better user experience for non-technical customers. The xFi app interface for managing the home network with Xfinity is much cleaner than that provided by stock or third-party modems and routers, which are generally made with little attention on the software side.

Xfinity also has an agenda with promoting their xFi routers, which is that they help support their public WiFi network. While they claim no security concerns since the networks are seperate, customers should be aware that any Xfinity hardware they own may be used as a node supporting their public WiFi network, which is used heavily by their Xfinity Mobile MVNO mobile phone service. 1

Summary: Xfinity charges more than most cable companies for WiFi equipment

In summary, you can save as much as $300 annually if you opt out of Xfinity's WiFi equipment and use your own.

However, you lose access to smart home and smart media features, so this is only recomended for customers who want internet-only service. If you're getting a TV bundle, home security, or other add-ons, you will be much happier buying into the xFi in-home WiFi system.

Xfinity WiFi fees summary

  • Performance Starter+ (25 Mbps plan): $14/mo.
  • Performance Select (100 Mbps plan): $14/mo.
  • Performance Pro+ (200 Mbps plan): $14/mo.
  • Blast! Pro+ (300 Mbps plan): $14/mo.
  • Extreme Pro+ (600 Mbps plan): $14/mo.
  • Gigabit (1000 Mbps plan): $14/mo.
  • Xfinity Internet Essentials (25 Mbps plan): WiFi equipment included

This page is based on a database of Xfinity plan pricing maintained by ConnectCalifornia. This page updates automatically as we update the database on a monthly basis. The last modification was made in September 2021.


Frequently Asked Questions

Why does Xfinity charge a WiFi fee?

Xfinity charges a $14 per month fee if you want to lease a gateway for your home WiFi. While customers can use their own equipment to remove the fee, this negates some features of Xfinity service such as the xFi app network management or xFinity voice control for TV.

How much does Xfinity charge for WiFi?

Xfinity charges $14 per month for basic WiFi service using their proprietary WiFi 6 Gateway devices. They have a premium WiFi plan which costs $25 per month, and includes mesh networking with xFi Pod devices, which are made in partnership with Plume. The premium WiFi plan includes unlimited data usage, which they normally charge $30 per month for as a standalone add-on.

Does Xfinity charge for WiFi on low-income plans?

Xfinity does not charge an incrimental WiFi fee on their Xfinity Internet Essentials program for low-income households. They include WiFi equipment free of charge for these customers, as part of the base $9.95 per month cost of internet-only service.

Page Summary
  • Xfinity charges a $14 WiFi fee on all internet-only plans except for their low-income Internet Essentials program.
  • $25 xFi Pod service provides mesh networking WiFi extenders for large homes, and includes some extra perks like unlimited data usage.
  • Using your own modem and router is permitted by Xfinity, and they remove the $14 per month fee if you opt to use your own equipment.

Author
Jameson Zimmer
Broadband Market Analyst
Author Bio →


Cite or share this page
Last Update: September 26, 2021
Published: February 13, 2021
CC BY-ND 4.0

When referencing ConnectCalifornia data and content on third-party sites, please provide linked attribution to the source page on www.connectcalifornia.com.