Starry Internet has recently emerged as a competitor to Xfinity in major markets across the US, with more major cities like San Francisco prepping to launch service in 2021.
While Starry has the best overall pricing for most users — particularly renters — there are some instances where Xfinity actually makes more sense in terms of price.
Starry is the best pick for cord cutters, thanks to the lack of data caps and low internet-only pricing.
Xfinity vs Starry Internet Basic Features
|Feature||Comcast Xfinity||Starry Internet|
|Starting price||$29.99/mo. sign-up price||$50/mo. flat rate|
|Download speed range||25–1,000 Mbps||200 Mbps|
|Upload speed range||3–35 Mbps||200 Mbps|
|Network type||Cable, Fiber||Fixed Wireless|
|Contract terms||Contract required for cheapest price||Contract-free|
Xfinity vs Starry Data Usage Policies
Many internet providers in California use data caps to manage their network, meaning that if you use more than a certain amount of data, you will be charged extra on top of your monthly bill.
Xfinity has data caps on some plans. 1.2TB is a common cap on Xfinity internet plans. Starry offers unlimited plans with no data caps.
Xfinity places data caps on some plans.
Starry offers internet plans with unlimited data
Xfinity vs Starry Net Neutrality Policies
Comcast has a public statement of support for Net Neutrality on their corporate website, but have removed some promises on the page related to paid prioritization of traffic in recent years.
Starry Internet maintains a detailed page on their website describing their traffic treatment in regards to Net Neutrality.
Xfinity vs Starry Pricing and Fees
Here is a breakdown of how common add-on fees compare for Xfinity and Starry plans. These types of fees are common with internet providers, and can result in larger bill each month.
|WiFi equipment fee||~$14/mo.||Free|
|Price increases||Bill increases after promo period||Flat rate|
|Early Termination Fee||Fee to cancel contract||Fee to cancel contract|
Note that fee amounts described above may vary by plan. See the plan comparison tables for Xfinity and Starry below for more information.
Xfinity vs Starry Internet-Only Plan Comparison
|Most Common Plan||Internet speed||Sign-up price||Final price||Avg price over 2 yrs|
|Performance Pro+ (Xfinity)||200 Mbps||$49.99/mo.||$70/mo.||$60/mo.|
|Starry Internet (Starry Internet)||200 Mbps||$50/mo.||$50/mo.||$50/mo.|
The price of the Xfinity Performance Pro+ internet plan is $49.99/month for the first 1 Year. However, the price then rises 40% to a final price of $70.
So, that means the price you actually pay for internet, averaged over two years, is $60/month.
Remember that Performance Pro+ includes the following fees when you compare pricing:
- $14/month fee for WiFi equipment
- Fees for using more than 1 TB
Starry Internet uses flat pricing for their entry-level Starry Internet plan. The $50 monthly cost does not rise over time.
Choosing between Xfinity and Starry plans
Xfinity’s extensive cable TV bundle options are the primary draw for their service. If you have a choice between Starry and Xfinity, and you prefer Netflix to traditional cable, Starry will almost certainly be the best value in terms of monthly price.
As a new company, Starry is also particularly focused on customer service, an area where Xfinity’s reputation is less strong.
Xfinity Internet Plans
|Plan Name||Download Speed||Promo Price||Final Price|
|Performance Starter+||25 Mbps||$29.99/mo||$50|
|Performance Select||100 Mbps||$34.99/mo||$55|
|Performance Pro+||200 Mbps||$49.99/mo||$70|
|Blast! Pro+||300 Mbps||$64.99/mo||$80|
|Extreme Pro+||600 Mbps||$74.99/mo||$90|
Starry Internet Plans
|Plan Name||Download Speed||Final Price|
|Starry Internet||200 Mbps||$50|
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Starry Internet cheaper than Comcast Xfinity?
Starry internet charges a flat $50 per month for 200 Mbps download and upload internet service. Xfinity has plans that start at a lower rate, but their plans have timed pricing, meaning that your rate will go up in your second and third year of service. Additionally, Xfinity has a maximum of 35 Mbps upload in the vast majority of their coverage area.
Is Starry Internet good for working from home?
Starry Internet has 200 Mbps upload speeds, making it a good choice for working from home since the bandwidth can easily support upload-intensive applications like Skype, and quickly move files to and from the cloud.
Is Starry Internet faster than Xfinity?
Starry Internet has faster uploads than Xfinity, with a standard 200 Mbps upload rate. Xfinity caps out at 35 Mbps upload, unless you can pay $300+ per month for their two-gig plan. Starry does not offer download speeds above 200 Mbps, while Xfinity offers download speeds up to 940 Mbps or more in most of their service area.